I can confirm that pps are changed and they have been a total cheat,last time i played pps was 6.5 months yes six and a half months my reward was 19960 promachos at lvl 156,i played again before 14 days i lost 60 million offence and 14 million defence and i cant still take at least my army back im not going to pay 600 euros for this cheat

tsunwu85rsa said:

Why do you keep throwing your armies against the persians when you know there is an element of gambling involved?

That's not true. It was always a guaranteed event if you calculated correctly.  That changed coming on about 3-4 weeks now and it seems like that is the case now.

PP were very beneficial and then you could revive 1000 or 10,000 agema on the 75% off.  

https://gyazo.com/8c12eb08df2ed465861bfb351e5b4c21

i put 380 promachos

200 myrmidions

800 swords

and bunch of defence in def positions

this is the payout i get

my res were full so pp doesnt pay me back in rss

followed all rules of pps

and this pennies is my payout

what is wrong with these positions

i just lost my def force in complete and alot of off force!!!!!

not playing positions ever again

nonsense

Ashu said:

With due respect i agree that i have made some grammatical mistakes, but if you read/focus on my Calculations, you will understand what am i trying to tell.

"The players use Positions to convert low quality troops into high quality troops. However, in reality, at the Persian Positions, it is the opposite. Let us look"

PP's work the "opposite? Are you stating that throwing high quality troops yields low quality troops? I believe that is correct-but why use high value troops at all? Are you advocating using high value troops?

I mean to say here that people are wrong in considering Cavalry and Phalanx as high quality troops because when we convert swordsman to agema, we are actually losing offense. Because Agema gives less offense for the payout size, while swordsman being cheaper, gives more offense on the given given payout size (payout size means the resource value of a full payout at a particular level).

---

"Players send swordsmen to positions because it is cheap, but in fact, it is reducing the prospect of gaining a large army as you are sending your good troops to convert into bad troops"

Converting swordsman into Agema's is bad? Converting Javs into Mounted Peltasts is bad?

Yes, i termed Swordsman/light & heavy infantry as good troops whereas phalanx and cavalry as bad troops. You would have to go through my calculations to know this, the first one states that we can produce 93.5% more offense at same resources through swordsman as compared to Agema Horseman. Same goes for Javelineer.

---

A.) "So suppose, to get to that bank we put in build Agema and Swordsman Simultaneously. Then the Swordsman would require 7,283,100 / 60 = 121,385 minutes Agema Horseman would require 7,283,100 / 115.6 approx. = 63,000 minutes only"

B.) "This means that we can have the strength of 24277 swordsmen in just 63,000 minutes, rather than 121,385 minutes through building Agema’s for Positions"

Okay - A states Swordsman strength takes 121,365 minutes to build and Agema's take 63,000 minutes to build.

         -  B states that we can have Swordsman strength in 63,000 minutes versus having Agema strength in 121,385

As you can see from the above, there appears to be a contradiction in your statements. If you could clarify further, here or PM,  I would be grateful.

Make it 'Swordsman' instead of 'Agema' at the last line. now the line would be, "This means that we can have the strength of 24277 swordsmen in just 63,000 minutes, rather than 121,385 minutes through building Swordsmen for Positions"

Hope it clears your doubts, i have edited the old spreadsheet system(didnt knew there was one made on the new system lol). You can find it here in this link, though you would not need it if you know the algorithm of persian positions and also that is it on the older system.

https://plarium.com/forum/en/sparta-war-of-empires/game-tutorials/44056_some-tools-and-guides/

Very nice job Ashu.

and nothing  is  wrong  with pp    except  they  don't give you what  you have put into them.  other wise  my rewards  would  be  in the 100k+  cav units

and  the banks,   if that is what it is called,  are  now stretched to what it was when there  was only 140 levels.      but  the  payouts   are tiny  compared to then.

As stated in other posts-I really do not play Xerxes on the frequency that some people here play. I don't understand or know if the bank re-sets, I don't know if there is a certain time to play Xerxes....whatever!! Who really knows?

When I do play Xerxes, i make sure of two cardinal rules:

1.) Resources are maxed in the city-yes, even if it means putting up a protection bubble to protect my city

2.) Light troops first, followed by a small array of heavy troops.

The whole point of using light troops is to win back higher troops (cavalry, phalanx) 

Does it take me "forever" to clear a position this way? Yes-absolutely!

But I am not blowing my army out and using high value troops and then screaming that Xerxes is not working.

Yes, the algorithm has changed somewhat according to people who play Xerxes on a regular basis-and again I state, I do not play Xerxes the way some people do-I lost my whole army when I started this game-and vowed never to do that again!!

 last week, one of my guys used his whole army on Xerxes and received 14K in Agema's. Fantastic! Now he has 14K of Agema's-and NO ARMY! Needless to say we cautioned him to stop and re-build-but he kept on going!

Even I have to admit, that something is not working correctly-but before I try and guess Plarium's banking system, or sit for hours at end looking at 23 different spreadsheets from those who say "I know how to play Xerxes" ..blah...blah...

 I will make sure my city resources are maxed out, and use "ONLY Light" troops to win cavalry and phalanx's.

Until someone contacts me with a method of playing Xerxes, I will continue to build troops and play very cautiously. 

The time and hard work in building an army after two years will not be lost to an unknown algorithm/method, hearsay, wild innuendo, and conjectures, which, judging by this thread and accompanying screenshots and statements made-seems to support an "evident truth".

Respect to all

Mick

I am glad that I was able to give some insight into the matter and hope it was helpful. Though, unfortunately, I will not be able to provide you with the "value" of Imperial Troops, or any Troops for that matter, that contributes to your reward in Persian Positions. But Tsunwu85rsa has created a very interesting test routine that could help you get a more clear idea of this value if you wish to pursue the testing further.

To reiterate, my personal opinion remains the same - it is best to use Regular Troops in Persian Positions and keep Imperial Troops for other tasks simply because one unfortunate loss can cost you a lot of valuable Units.

I m from the players I m not sucking Plarium but in this occasion Plarium Moderators and Community managers have right... PP working perfectly for those they know to play and they arent gabling... 

1st.  you need to play positions on same bank. If positions of this bank is finished you wait next day to refill... Gablers playing all positions and share the invest on different banks without refilling the bank. After going to the forum and babycrying...

2nd. stop playing the one bar system. Its old and Xerxes knows it well to make you loose yr army.. Play always different system and when a bank give you a payout change and invest to different bank..

3rd. stop using lights and heavies on Xerxes. Take ages to refill xerxes bank. Use them to PVP tournaments as there the logarithm change (there is the main problem) and any other army use there is waste.. You ll never recover yr looses from the pvp army bonus if you use cavalry or phalanx to pvp... Yr lights and heavies you take from Xerxes keep them in acropolis for the upcoming pvp to invest in Phalanx...

4th. make Xerxes to give loans and not invest on Xerxes bank.. At the moment i own to Xerxes up to 8 k promachones and I m sure next week I ll get another loan from him. With my system I make 10 k promachones monthly and my target is in 3 months to make 20 k prom monthly without using them at all on Xerxes.. I love when I own army to Xerxes and not Xerxes own army to me. He is always try to get it back and he falls in my trap...

5th, The most important not only for this game but for real gabbling also...Any machine or logarithm built to cheat on players has imperfections for the inverse analogy ... That gives the opportunity on high intelligent players to cheat on the machine or to the logarithm... Nothing is perfect on this world, me either...

dinah.gabriel83 said:

Sorry dude your boring im well aware of the systems did you not read my post. And in fact you sound like you are clearly sucking up to plarium just with the way you write your sentences this is 1st time im having problems with pp so before you get on your high horse and how good you are and what you expect save it. I posted in hear as it states positions not working so im adding to that assumption. Dorieas perhaps you should make a new post stating that positions are not broken  because unless your fixing my positions your post is useless to my problem as i play the positions correctly 

I been suspend several times from forum not as Tonaya but a lot. I m not from the loved ones and I dont care...

I belived you  I was up to writing the third step down and there is not a persion bank i was wondering where it was on the game  dam Iam stupid  stoped writing and started reading  and it hit me  there is really not a payout  there never will be so Sparta tricked me well us iam so dam stupid but i get it thank you 

Rix...I don't normally give away secrets for free, but you seem like a nice guy so I'm going to give you the secret to winning big against Persians. It's a 5 step method so get a pen and paper and write this down....it will change your Sparta experience and maybe even change the dynamics of Sparta as a whole.

Step 1: Calculate your total strength of both your offense and defense

Step 2: Insert your entire army, both offense and defense, into the persian bank. Yes!! Until nothing is left.

Step 3: Go to the nearest grocery store and buy rice, peanut butter, one of those big jugs of distilled water (this will be your meals for the next month...add some bananas if you have kids), and a bottle of vodka.

Step 4: Drink the bottle of vodka (such an important step) until your actually dumb enough to spend real money on this game

Step 5: Go to the revive tab and revive the 50 million that you lost....clear a position 140 or higher and BOOM!!!! 10 million payout! After a couple months you'll be a beast the likes the hellas have never seen!

There ya go bud! Clear instructions on how to dominate this game. Hope it helps. Look me up in game if you have any questions!