Hello Plarium Team,
Here is a short open letter addressed to you that I am putting here. I don't know where to, that is why here:
My name is Nikolay Dimitrov, my Game ID is 26574894, my nickname 戦士 Gultia an I am with SNS clan (or what is left of it).
I am doing this, because I see that MA is at a crucial turning point and sharing feedback is very important now. I will explain what I think in 3 parts - 1. where I come form / why I chose this game; 2. what is happening now; 3.what can be done / changed.
1.1 - Who am I - I am former pretty close to what you can call a ProGamer in 90's and 2000's. With three words - ex "No Lifer". I have invested years of gameplay and countless 24-72 hours raids on the following games:
- D2 - Hardcore mode only
- L2 - Countless servers and battles for supperiority on the servers.
- WoW - until TBC
- Different mobile games for 2 years period.
- War Robots - for about an year, with pretty heavy investments. - arround 5000$
Why I spend on mobile games? Simple! Because now I am a familly guy with wife and kids and there is no justification to me anymore to grind the game when I can aford to pay and spend time with my familly. How much I spend on MA I will not reveel, but Plarium can easyly check that.
1.2 - Why MA - Like I have mentioned I came from War Robots and why so, the answers are two:
- I saw for an year that they (Pixonic) have no regards for the spending users (after all the game end goal is to make money - lets be honest about it) and quickly rotate prised stuff to be outdated. Simply Pixonic's
greed is discourageing us to spend, but that is my lesser issue with WR.
- The game IS FAKING SLOW. Imagine comming from D2 Hardcore where your 2 years development can die in a single second, if you don't pay attention. I better watch the grass grow than play WR. And then my son introdused me to Mech Arena.
...Ahhh, what a relieve! - Supper fast paste game with closer CPs and different in usage mechs, which you can use only onece in your hangar... and there is a KillShot that charges and scrables enemy's teamplay..
I was hooked immidiatelly to the point that MA was the only game I play. Later Surge came arround. That made the game even faster. Pilots, new mechs, nerfs of old weapons, introduction of new mechs and weapons made the game even faster than before. That made me want to play competitively and quickly I have changed several clans until I have found a clan with stable play and voice communication in english.
The game was fast and was exclusively skill based. If you develop good skills you can compete. Yes, it requires some investment to aquire the meta mechs and weapons, but out of that the best skills + teamwork + communication wins. The game was so good that even 3rd party tournaments emerged, and even good ones.
The essense of the game and the reason why everybody played MA was a fast paste game, where every little mistake is brutally punished, so the best team to emerge as a winner.
2. What is going on now - After the introdiction of the shield mods all that "skill based - no mistake allowed - best to win" corelation disappeared. Now everything is slow. Now everyone can survive (win) his/her mistakes. Now I can't kill a mech with a single salvo/magazine of both of my weapons (just like in War Robots) togather. There is no difference, if shoot entire magazine SRacks12 or Railgun12/16 or EmRifles12/16. The result is the same - barely removing the shields. That tells me that there is no insentive to take and guard key positions on the maps with middle mechs. Now a every position can be attacked. There is no stratigic points anymore. Here are some examples:
- No point of taking a roof key position with LaceWing + SRack 12/Railgin12/EM Rifle 12 in order to deny access to particular routes/possitions. Now everybody can survive those with no HP lost.
- No point of guarding key position with Eclipse + SRack 12/Railgin12/EM Rifle 12 in order to deny access to particular routes/possitions. Now everybody can survive those with no HP lost.
- No point of guarding key position with Surge + EM Gun12/SRack12/Railgin12/EM Rifle12 in order to deny access to particular routes/possitions. Noone cares, because we have crit/back damage denyle mod, which randers Surge useless.
Do you see the trend? All the fast gameplay making mechs/wepons combinations are out. Only big, chunky, and slow combinations are good to use now.
- Tanks + MiniGun 12/16
- Tanks + "The new yellow Minigun" 12/16
- Tanks + "The fishing harpoon" 12/16
To be clear. I am not bitching, because I don't have the mechs/weapons that are META now. I have all mechs/weapons that are not trash, so this cannot be an argument. I am bitching, because Mech Arena starts to smell like War Robots - slow and boring like observing how my grand-grand mother is folding socs.
It is so bad, that yesterday I have showed my son (which doeas not play MA form years now): "Look I am going to shoot to this robot (with two SRack12) and I will not do any damage on the HP of the mech." And sure thing. No actual HP was taken from the mech (because of anti-back/crit mod + shield mod), without even taking in account the HP mod. I have spend (no joking) 3 entire magazines of 2x SRack 12 to kill tha damn thing. At that point every 5 years old on the other side can just run away. Very, very, very interesting and trilling gameplay.
So thrilling gameplay, that a good chunk of my clan left the game. They just uninstalled the application. Players that have 2+ years of playing in the same clan were so thrilled from the gameplay that unistalled the game.
Yes some of them do not spend as much as I do and most of their equipment is rendered useless now. Ok, you are going to lose those players in every big change in the META (like with DLs). That is understandable. But a lot of players are going away, because the game is no longer that high-skill/high-reward now.
And here is the proof: When DLs+EM Rifles were nerfed noone of my clan stopped playing. Some bitched for 2 days and that was it. Now - I have never seen such low clan players activity in my entire MA experience. And [SNS] is not a joke-clan. People know that.
3. Possible sollutions - To be honest there are several possible paths forward. Every single each of them with different tradeoffs. The one that looks less harmful for everybody is tha path of co-existance and natural selection.
Plarium can make Mods as a separate game mode (like Tournamest; 2v2; CPC; 5v5; Single Player) and revert the Normal (fast paste) gamplay for the rest of the modes. In that case people that enjoy MA for the fast paste games can continue play that unique style and people that want more biffy and survivable play can enjoy that as well. Plarium can make Mods mode to be engaging and rewarded. To give ensentive to play that mode as well with different rewords. In that manner natural selection will decide which mode people play and spend on more, so Plarium can focus more on the particular mode.
The way that is handled/forced now does no good to anyone.
In closure:
I believe that the most powerful vote (ballet) that men can cast is the one you cast with your wallet... and I am pretty close to change my voting on Mech Arena.
Gultia