RIX said:

If there is a coalition with 5 people in it, that is a waste, there is no need.

My coalition is a waste?

Each hegemon manages his coalition as he sees fit.

I create my coalition to be able to make tutorials and help people, I do not care what they connect and whether or not they help me whenever I can I will help them.

And now it turns out that that is not profitable and they throw away our work for years, in my case more than 3, to the rubbish bin? not counting the drachmas spent (in my case only drachmas but in other real money).

if only active players remain who will make sieges for the weekly top?

Friend Rix, thank you for defending us.

rix,  i understand what you say, but wahts the diference of being in a coa or not? f there are coas is because palrium let them created & paid them but now they ahve ddecided that 15 days is enough time to take from them what they paid... 

do you understand the problem? imagine you pay for somethng in game, you go on holidays 15 days and when youare back, palrium decided you are not owrth that units, or bonus or etc that you bought, this is the same,,,,

elias said:

RIX said:

If there is a coalition with 5 people in it, that is a waste, there is no need.

My coalition is a waste?

Each hegemon manages his coalition as he sees fit.

I create my coalition to be able to make tutorials and help people, I do not care what they connect and whether or not they help me whenever I can I will help them.

And now it turns out that that is not profitable and they throw away our work for years, in my case more than 3, to the rubbish bin? not counting the drachmas spent (in my case only drachmas but in other real money).

if only active players remain who will make sieges for the weekly top?

If your coalition comprises of 5 people and you fear that less than 60% of your coalition is active......then you answered your own question my friend.

and to your last comment on this quote, that was the question I am trying to get answered. I believe any coalition with low participation should be disbanded BUT I do not believe that they should delete the accounts and create more pools.  DID YOU NOT READ MY RESPONSE?

And of course we appreciate all of your contributions to the game forum.  

Fortuna said:

do you understand the problem? imagine you pay for somethng in game, you go on holidays 15 days and when youare back, palrium decided you are not owrth that units, or bonus or etc that you bought, this is the same,,,,

Again, this rule seems to apply to coalitions that have less than 60% participation, in order to remain active, simply remove a player. If a coalition has 57% active players and face elimination and you have 1 member on vacation for 30 days, why do you have to remove player on vacation? You just have to remove one inactive player that's been gone for a long time and has never communicated with you

Obviously you keep the member that is on holiday because they told you they were and you make a note.

So if I have 50 members inactive, 1 is on holiday and 49 of them have been missing for hundreds of days, why would i remove the guy on holiday????

rix, i understand what you say, but wahts the diference of being in a coa or not? f there are coas is because palrium let them created & paid them but now they ahve ddecided that 15 days is enough time to take from them what they paid...

That is incorrect. If the coalition has less than 60% participation for 14 days the "coalition is removed and inactives turned into pools. We all know that almost every coalition has players inactive for 100,200,300+ days. It is very easy for a coalition to remain alive by removing those inactive players if there is danger of being eliminated. The hegemon and an polemarch can handle this simple task.

I hope you understand what I mean 

 please open your mind to see that are other realities to the only one that you mention, yes i udnerstand long termn inactives, but here is something different... we are talking about situations like the following, not only like you say, logn term inactives

for example, 1 .... you are hedgemon, you get ill, you come back, plarium has taken out your coalition from you?

is this ok for you? (two year ago i was in hospital for nearly 3 weeks , intensive care,  and in bed other 2... with this new thing i would have find myself out of coa and if i was hedgemon out of position....)

2. you work for military forces and have turns of 3 weeks or 3 months out of internet... when you are back all is gone?

3. work reasons family reason... many reasons to be a month off even vacation... now, when you are back all is gone?

I can keep giving you real example of real players like this...

A terrible feature which should be removed.

 please open your mind to see that are other realities to the only one that you mention, yes i udnerstand long termn inactives, but here is something different... we are talking about situations like the following, not only like you say, logn term inactives

for example, 1 .... you are hedgemon, you get ill, you come back, plarium has taken out your coalition from you?

is this ok for you? (two year ago i was in hospital for nearly 3 weeks , intensive care,  and in bed other 2... with this new thing i would have find myself out of coa and if i was hedgemon out of position....)

2. you work for military forces and have turns of 3 weeks or 3 months out of internet... when you are back all is gone?

3. work reasons family reason... many reasons to be a month off even vacation... now, when you are back all is gone?

I can keep giving you real example of real players like this...

Plarium,i am waiting 4 days for your answer,about legal issue of your new update for coalition activity.....

its monday,you did show up on work,right?

just to be clear,i asked plarium workers,Alina,Andrew,Helga,Pawel,Dimitri,....anyone from management....

Tonaya

Hey, Tonaya.

Dimitri here, dropping by while Alina is unavailable. 

Please check out the Terms of Use, specifically articles 1 and 5, that should answer your question. 

Marius said:

Hey, Tonaya.

Dimitri here, dropping by while Alina is unavailable. 

Please check out the Terms of Use, specifically articles 1 and 5, that should answer your question. 

Having seen similar reactions of the Facebook servers when Coalition Activity was introduced, I can assure you that it is not as bad as it might seem at a glance. Facebook players voted it as the best new feature of the year a few months later and I have no doubt once you guys have a chance to test it and see that your Coalitions are not just going to be dissolved overnight, you will enjoy the Coalition Activity rewards a lot more.

i think you didnt understood me at all.

you dont own what you sold.

you sold me 4 years ago option to build coalition,and i bought it,now it is mine,it is not yours,so you dont have what to care about my coalition you already sold to me.will i boot inactive players,or i will wait some to get back from holiday...its my busyness,not yours.you didnt mention any condition about activity when you offered me to buy coalition,so what you want to do is illegal and against the law(i dont know about israel law,maybe its different then the rest of the world)

btw,i do have and build one city on fb server,to educate one moderator about his behavior,so i do know whats going on on fb server,you killed a lot coalitions with that update.

try to listen first time in your life,remove this update from plarium.com

Tonaya

also about fb players not complaining about it, i guess it is like the problem of the guardians and the coa attacks, they had guardians for many months and nothing was said, but in the first day of having guardians in plarium.com, we realised the problem and we came here in the forum to explain the problem and why and what was wrong so its gets sorted as sson as possible...

you jsut said nicely with no bad words that we dont know what we want, that you know better for us..  and there is nothing we can do...

thats  so wrong lol that i wont began with it...

another lost battle

i guess when you manage to make us leave sparta will be a win for you or game over?

guys if you dont take the reward you miss nothing cause the reward is nothing only waste time also like the other ne implated things.

you jsut said nicely with no bad words that we dont know what we want, that you know better for us..  and there is nothing we can do...

thats  so wrong lol that i wont began with it...

another lost battle

i guess when you manage to make us leave sparta will be a win for you or game over?

i already know people loosing their coas, specially in august, a month of holidays (great timming plarium) , but you know better that all of us ... who am i to give my opinion, isnt it?

its not a matter of being horrible, its a matter of a game that does not respect the players... 

hijadelafortuna said:

i already know people loosing their coas, specially in august, a month of holidays (great timming plarium) , but you know better that all of us ... who am i to give my opinion, isnt it?

its not a matter of being horrible, its a matter of a game that does not respect the players... 

Your opinion is always welcomed :)

I understand why you don't like this feature, but my opinion is still the same: Coalition dismissal can be avoided and if you have an active Coalition, you have nothing to worry about.

or increase the days, i am not against liberating long term inactive players, but i think the margen you gave suddenly is very short

hijadelafortuna said:

or increase the days, i am not against liberating long term inactive players, but i think the margen you gave suddenly is very short

Devs already increased it. 

In the initial implementation of the feature on social servers, Coalitions were dismissed after 7 days of activity below 60%.

Now they're dismissed if it's below 60% for 14 days.

its not enough

and 7 days is atrocious... way to go if you want people to leave game :)

One of the reason i stayed in sparta being worse game than others of its style was that if i put troops in acropolis city was safe and nothing will happend to my city and if  buy my coalition... in cases like i get sick, or my family or i am busy out or holidays or travelling etc...

now you take out one of the two good things this game has

I see myself back to grepolis, if things don't change :)

hijadelafortuna said:

its not enough

and 7 days is atrocious... way to go if you want people to leave game :)

One of the reason i stayed in sparta being worse game than others of its style was that if i put troops in acropolis city was safe and nothing will happend to my city and if  buy my coalition... in cases like i get sick, or my family or i am busy out or holidays or travelling etc...

now you take out one of the two good things this game has

I see myself back to grepolis, if things don't change :)

Unfortunately, this feature won't be removed.