They adjusted the amount of attack scrolls to match the number of defense posts.  If the enemy clan has over 60 defense positions the extra attacks go to the clan leader and deputies first.

Weve asked them to change this so clan leaders can assign who gets the extra attacks.

As of last weeks update, instead of everyone in the clan getting 3 scrolls each (90 total if you have 30 members) a clan only gets 65 scrolls split between all members, with the left overs going to the leader and deputies.

It's one of many things in the last month where the devs have said "hey, a lot of players are telling us there's a major problem, let's completely ignore what *specifically* they're saying about it and instead make it worse"

You dont see a problem with clan leader deciding who would get the extra scrolls, wow reaaly?

Clan will purposely give the scrolls to the people with stromgest teams.

How is the clan leader deciding who gets the extra scrolls fair. hell why just have the clan leader give out all the scrolls.

how about this, if you dont have enough clans members, go recruit?

why should clans with less then 30 get the same scrolls as a clan that has 30?

hell why your at in clan verse clan when clans are under 30 let the clan leader decide who should get a mulipler because they are short people.

Let them lose, the people in the clan will leave and go to a clan that has 30 problem fixed

they once again created a problem that did not need fixing.

No, I really don't see a problem with it.  Why would you not want your extra attack scrolls going to your strongest PvP members?  

what i am saying why should clans that do not have 30 get the scrolls normalized and then the clan with less be able to give thise scrlls to the best people

you really see no issue with that?

you dont see high level clusters purposely having less then 30 for this exact reason

the most fair way is you get scrolls according to number of members

every member gets the smae number of scrolls regardless if you dont have 30

why clan that cant field 30 get a handicap

it should be the other way the clans that can field 30 should get a bonus because its harder to keep a clan of 30 then less

your logic is incentivizing having less

then if clan with less then 30 get the extra attacj scrolls to give to whoeer they want why the clan that has 30 give thier scrolls out the same way?

dont you see the advantage if you get pic who gets the extra scrolls? 

so based on your logic here IN CVC clans that cant field 30 should get a multipler to make up the difference since they dont have 30

please explain how the 2 are different?

its the clans fault can field 30 that the other another clan field 30 no

you want fair then leave the clan your in to one that can field 30 or continue to loose

И вот новая Осада. И снова вопрос? Где баланс по свиткам Атаки? И по какой причине Мой Клан ВСЕГДА имеет меньше свитков Атаки, чем у противника? Я не спрошу у вас, почему у нас снова противник, уже побеждавший нас. Но клан противника, опять имеет преимущество в колличестве свитков Атаки. На момент старта Осады у противника было 28 человек в клане у нас 28 человек в клане. Замок и у них и у нас 2го уровня. Тогда почему их рядовые члены клана имеют по 3 свитка Атаки, когда наши имею по 2? Вы сами то понимаете насколько это всё нелепо? И да сейчас вы мне скажете, что на момент старта подбора противника у нас было 30 человек в клане. Но это же глупо, за 2 человека лишних давать дополнительно 19 свитков атаки???? Или это не так и противник явно манипулирует правилами для получения преимущества над нами??? И уже не в первый раз. Не хорошо.

Название клана противника brucey bonus....Их клан лидер -storey-  . С удовольствием посоревнуемся с ними на равных условиях, но на условиях манипуляции со свитками атаки. Хорошо если с их строноны, но если со стороны Плариума, то простите, это невозможно. Прошу разобраться с этой вопиющей несправедливостью.

*Still* had to force close Raid and relaunch to get a battle to load in under half an hour

I actually had no lag (1st time ever) loading battles, I know others did in my cluster though.

i

My reply is just a subtle excuse to post my stellar performance this week against a top 100 clan.  We need to get better at tanking...

Super demoralizing for my guys this week. The other clan has 1 team that just none of us can beat. It'd be one thing if we were totally overmatched, but it's just this one single fight that none of us can crack holding up thier stronghold.

Mythic heavy team?

So when are we (Leadership) going to be able to better distribute donated Florins? We can at least use donated Mana Orbs anywhere but getting Clan Members to donate to the right tower is like herding chickens lol.

Or at least let us refund the Florins to clan members so they can donate it to the right spot... 

I've been fortunate that with clear communication that everyone has donated exactly where I needed now for a number of upgrades. Stronghold twice, four towers.

I can say that they are working on better leadership tools for Siege though. 

To be honest I'm more looking forward to Instant Hydra and Background Multis than any other Siege changes first. :D

Actually no

Ankora, Tormin, Horsey, Harima

High speed, stoneskin, 6* blessings

In one attempt I used 4 champs in stoneskin myself, and Harima 1-shotted the whole team through SS anyway

That would be nice.

no recibo los cofres cumpliendo creo yo los requisitos , hay algun error en plarium

Looking at this a few months on and i think this has been good content if i am honest

We have won maybe 60% of our match ups so it seems reasonable with regards to matchmaking, and the rewards for winning are good.

The cost to repair buildings has been fixed, and from a clan persepective this content more than any other gets the quiet people in the clan talking as we try to clear the path to the garrison etc. The clan feels much more alive during siege (a better chat feature would be good though)

A decent job done, thanks to plarium listening to feedback, i wish everyone got 3 scrolls however.

I'm really really enjoying Siege. 

I love the strategy of setting up the defenses. And I really like how my whole clan is trying to improve their teams and champs now, it's been a real group effort.

Dang, that must be some kind of next-level Harima build. I am pretty happy with my Harima build, but she could not blow through stoesekin on 4 well-built toons.

My advice for Siege: Clan Roles based on Siege History/Performance. I switched up clan roles, but before I did I gave everyone a heads up as to why: Letting people know that the roles aren't based on Tenure or Friendship ect stuff right now, it's gonna be based on Siege and who is/isn't contributing just to balance the scrolls.

We did great on this Siege that just ended.

ONE THING THO: For the love of god, when siege ends can we PLEASE still be able to see the Siege Stats for the most recent Siege? As soon as it ends it sets everyone to 0 for Atk/Def ect despite the next siege being 2 weeks away...