You wrote all of that without realising my point: if SP is so inaccurate, how can you tell someone is 3 times your strength?
And strength isn't the only thing to consider - skill plays a role. Often I find the MM gives me a rather strong opponent, and I only realise when checking their hangar after I've won.
Hell, I'd argue a 12K to 20K is a much worse gap than 3K to 7K or something, even if the latter is technically a larger percentage difference.
And if you've not been living under a rock, I shouldn't have to go point out all the changes they've made to make the normal matchmaking better, and ended up also making it easier to abuse - it's happened quite a few times, which is one of the reasons they are recently more subtle with their tweaks.
If you look back when they first started doing large MM experiments with tournament, sooo many people spoke out and complained, because they did a larger test, it didn't entirely go as planned and people got mad about it.
Gear hub being "looked down upon" is your opinion. The gear hub was 100% an improvement. I wouldn't have 75% of the items I do if it wasn't for it.
Maybe you're referring to the grade update, which was good and bad. It put an end to oppression by artillery, which I sure as hell don't miss - and it made the game more intuitive. A rare and uncommon item shouldn't be top meta when legendary items are a thing. Yeah there are some things that I'd like to still want be strong, like Tengu (#BUFFTENGU, or well a legendary version (pls Plarium I need it)) - and I would've preferred if the gap had been a bit smaller - but some of those things for many players have had a legendary version release - like lacewing for lancer, nomad for killshot and such.
And you could also argue that many of the 'legendary' items should be either be buffed or reduced in grade (without touching the stats I mean), like scorpius, for this intuitiveness to really be carried all the way through - and I'd agree.
In my experience, the main issue the matchmaking has atm is a tourney one to do with large teams versus collections of randoms - both at higher and lower SP I've played a lot and the matchmaking seems generally fine.
I'm also not saying Plarium shouldn't make it fairer because it makes it more exploitable - again you've missed my point - the point was that it isn't SIMPLE. As a game I know this, matchmaking is HARD. Harder than you probably think. I mean, to maximise satisfaction, how do you make a system were everybody ends up winning >50% of the time?
I never said Plarium shouldn't work on the MM - you've entirely misunderstood what I'm saying - it's not perfect and never will be, certainly as the game continues to evolve. I'm just saying that maybe you should cut them some slack instead of deciding that it's actually as easy as clicking your fingers.
While draws exist, drawing a match is incredibly unsatisfying. You got so close to winning.. except it slightly wasn't enough.
People would rather win some and lose some instead of draw all the time.
Also, like, you are really making an argument about draws when CPC is the main gamemode most people at least prefer to play - and influence is stored as a Float, remember?
Also also, have you considered that they don't like telling how the matchmaking works for number 1 because that's basically giving away stuff that costs them money to figure out for free, and number 2 because if people know how the MM works, it makes it a lot easier to exploit.