it is more an issue of the guys that did half measures

if you have a player that worked on gear but did not dedicate the time and effort that the big guys did - to get a full set and max the level - they are kind of screwed

lower level people that have not done any positions ever have full set - and an inventory stuffed full of tier-4 gear waiting to break

(they are complaining that they get gear much faster than they can possibly break it)

they are upgrading gear at an astounding rate

the high levels have maxed gear already

the mid level guys that purchased a little gear (the 3 legendarys you can buy) or that worked their position levels to somewhere around 100 to 120 and earned a piece or 2 of top tier legendary gear, but did not dedicate the number of troops or time to getting full sets of gear - they are being surpassed by everyone else

not exactly a balanced game play - 

it is frustrating the guys that worked hard for years to get the advantage the gear offered

it is not fair to the guys that spent some money but not large amounts, or that did some serious labour to get gear, but cant compete with the guys that did nothing, or the guys that already have the gear

but i admit it is a massive boon for the alt accounts and low level players that make up the majority of the sparta population - top tier generals gear with out ANY effort, and completely free of charge.

Theokoles said:

Yes - it is still going on.

Members of our coalition - including myself - have found coalition chests with 50 coffers plus keys, 30 coffers plus keys, and piles of 12's, and 9's.

They come in legendary tier4, legendary tier1, rare tier3, uncommon tier3, uncommon tier1 - all coffers and keys from a single chest will be identical 

The rarity of the chest does not seem to effect the content when it comes to coffers, however players of higher levels, and that have unlocked high level positions do not receive these as content of coalition chests.

Accounts under level 80 that have never done a position in the past seem to get them the most frequently.

Hello!

The reward in Coalition Chests is given randomly.

The General's Equipment you receive doesn't depend on your level, on how many PP you played and so on.

Theokoles said:

This is an issue that needs to be forwarded to the dev team and fixed.

Outright denial of player concerns is a large part of the reason that the forums are dead - and people no longer post things here.

I forwarded it to them already. The reply was: they're given randomly. 

Devs information is the main base for information I post on Forum.

Hola Alina Phoenix

se que nadie en el mundo es perfecto y lo entiendo, pero como jugador activo y constante que soy he visto muchos errores que nos afectan de una u otra forma a muchos jugadores por ejemplo esos cofres, Como dijo mi amigo Yaviz imaginate niveles 50 - 60 con mejores generales que un nivel 90 - 100 es imposible... traten de enmendar sus errores con motivaciones para que a la final los jugadors no se cansen y dejen el juego por que esa es la realidad ya muchos cada dia se retiran y pues es algo logico, no solo por los errores sino por todo lo nuevo que ha salido, Guardianes, Trampas, Xp unidades etc... cada dia parece mas un trabajo que un juego y esto beneficia siempre mas al que juega con dinero que a los que jugamos por cuenta propia (sin meter Dinero) pues para nosotros es casi imposible tener un Guardian calidad 5 o 4, nos dan muy pocos epicos y sacros y pues nisiquiera ponen un monto en gemas o dracmas para comprarlos sino con dinero ajuro y no deberia ser asi..... y eso es solo un ejemplo de muchos mas que hay en el juego.

Esto es un juego no solo piensen en el Beneficio Economico sino tambien en el beneficio de todos los jugadores sin dejar a ninguno por fuera, analicen y hagan mejor las cosas para poder estar agusto en el jueg y recuerden que no todos tenemos millones y millones para gastar en el juego muchos hemos llegado lejos con esfuerzo y dandole duro dia a dia como yo.

Gracias y Saludos, Itorres

Hello, Alina Phoenix

I know that nobody in the world is perfect and what is entering, but as an active and constant player I am I have seen many mistakes that has been a form of many others for example those chests, As my friend Yaviz said imagine levels 50 - 60 with better generals than a level 90 - 100 is impossible ... try to amend your mistakes with motivations so that in the end the players do not get tired and leave the game for that to be the reality and many days they retire and it is something logical, not only for the mistakes but for everything new that has come out, Guardians, Traps, Xp units, etc. Every day seems more a job than a game and this always benefits more than a game of money that we play on our own (without Money meter) because for us it is almost impossible to have a Guardian quality 5 or 4, they give us very few epic and sacral and because it is not even an amount in gems or drachmas to buy them but with money and it should not be like that ..... and that is just one example of many more in the game

This is a game to not only think about the Economic Benefit but also the benefit of all players while still being outside, analyze and do better things to be able to agitate in the game and remember that not all of us have millions and millions to spend in the game many of us have gone far with effort and giving him hard day to day like me.

Thanks and regards, Itorres

it have already created de-balance in the game, I know many players who bought this offer and that being level 60, now they have a better general than me, this discourages me as a player, and to say that it was a mistake does not fix anything, every time I am more disappointed With the plarium policy and I am not alone, they are abandoning the game more and more players.

Honestly, I can hardly trust the excuses that plarium offers us, when it comes to money.

Hello, Archons!

The initial Offer should have contained Units, not Chests.

Unfortunately, there was a mistake in the offer that was enabled in the game first and instead of Units some players got chests.

As soon as we noticed it, the balance was changed to the correct one.

At the moment, we can't remove the chests players get as they opened them already. We also can't run this offer again as it will lead to the disbalance of the Hero feature in general.

I understand you feel offended and I'm really sorry this situation happened. Devs will add a protection in our admin system that will prevent cases like this one in the future.

jeff hellman said:

They are giving away these now in coalition chests, I have several reports of members getting these legendary chests and the keys in large nos, though it does seem to be the higher level persian players that seem to get them (ie probably dont need most of them) but I agree after years of toil and the inital purchase of 3 chests + keys, they are now old news and once again the players who sacrificed money and troops to get them they now are demeaned in plariums way of thinking. They are promoting Guardians now and all those specific packs what drachma cant buy as there latest revenue boosters to the spenders. Stay patient players, one day Guardians will go this way also, when they dream up their next revenue boosters of which the coiners will bound to want and be first. Stay patient.

correct hellman, they are giving them away for free to small players not to active higher level ones, why the hell wants top general players with less than ten millions, i was in shock i stopped looking for the second defense ring and now a small player has all brand new for free... and repeated... is this a con?

every report I have seen on moderator chats and staffer chats state it was uploaded by mistake and that it shouldn't have been available to anyone at the level it was 

Instead of so much apology, compensate their players for what happened.

Also as itorres says, there are many things, every time there is a mistake in the game, you take many months to solve them, each time the game goes worse, restart the app every 2 minutes, everything is blocked, it is unplayable, with the money that plarium win should be able to have the best programmers in the world and the best servers, is unacceptable.

And the withdrawal of the wrong offer for fear of unbalancing the game .... I do not believe it .. all the mistakes they say they commit are not mistakes are tricks to earn more money. Please, be serious, ¿unbalanced?

Bonus 50% $$ + Bonus city 15% $$ + Guardian orange 115% $$ + bonus xp 40% $$ + intellect bonus level 15 to 25 approximately 25% $$

And they want us to believe that they have withdrawn the offer because they are worried about the imbalance?

There is rumor by the server.

they put the offer for 3 to 4 hours with the idea of ​​winning a lot of money and then they withdrew it with the excuse that it was a mistake.

I insist it is not good to say sorry, take responsibility for your mistakes and give solutions.

It is a pity that during the last year, plarium has been corrupted by money and has destroyed the game. There is more to see, that more and more players leave the game, even very visas players.

I love the game, but every time I lose more and more the desire to play for my great disappointment towards plarium.

This is an issue that needs to be forwarded to the dev team and fixed.

Outright denial of player concerns is a large part of the reason that the forums are dead - and people no longer post things here.

What do you base this information on Alina?

All evidence we have ... everything we see and know tells us that this is not random.

If it was meant to be random, then you have a massive error in your programming because it is not.

To my knowledge - you are the ONLY person that feels it is random.  Saying it is so does not make it so.

Yes - it is still going on.

Members of our coalition - including myself - have found coalition chests with 50 coffers plus keys, 30 coffers plus keys, and piles of 12's, and 9's.

They come in legendary tier4, legendary tier1, rare tier3, uncommon tier3, uncommon tier1 - all coffers and keys from a single chest will be identical 

The rarity of the chest does not seem to effect the content when it comes to coffers, however players of higher levels, and that have unlocked high level positions do not receive these as content of coalition chests.

Oh my! I can't say that I am happy to see what happened with those chests but at the same time I am not terribly upset. 

A lower level player that does not do high level positions or spend much on the game will likely never get the amount of pieces to get maximum benefit from the legendary gear anyway.

Most top players have all the pieces anyway and have had them maxed for a while now. 

If you don't have a full set I get that it stings a bit to see that, but I do believe it was an honest mistake and hopefully the developers can make some improvements / additions to the generals gear that can keep that feature moving forward. 

If anything perhaps it's time to add a higher tier of general gear. Maybe a more powerful mythic level that if completely maxed out can offer another 10-20% boost to combat stats when completed? 

Of course it would have to be incredibly rare and the cost to upgrade high. 

That will give advanced players something to work on long term with the projected time to get the full set with max levels taking 1-2 years.

Then perhaps we can loosen up the rarity of the current gear and give everyone else a chance to catch up a little bit, thus making completed legendary sets more of the norm with variations in individual power being the number of upgrades performed. 

My group have been watching and recording the 9 coffer drops from coalition chests.

Things changed a few weeks ago - now they drop in groups of 6 or 9 - it is not just 9 anymore, but they still gift large numbers.

What we have noticed is that the accounts of levels 70 to 83 seem to get them constantly (almost every account in that range has found 18 to 78 legendary tier-4 items) the accounts from level 84 to 89 have seen much less (from zero to 18)   and the accounts above 89 do not find any (zero coffers across 14 accounts ... as in never seen a tier-4 legendary drop)

it would appear that the drops are not random at all as friends with high rank in other coalitions are telling me that they do not see these chests in their high level accounts ever (mind you they have not been looking or recording drops) but constantly find them in lower level (80 ish) accounts.

I would value input from other players here - are you guys finding multi coffer drops from coalitions chests?  What level is your city?

I am interested to know if it is just bad luck for our group? or are other people finding lower level accounts seem to be finding way more of these items.

(our test group is only 42 accounts and has watched well over 200 coalition chests)

the x3 multiplayer is very much like the erroneous drachma pack that was offered by mistake from palarium during their x11 sale

were the 3 generals gear items plus keys just supposed to be the "jackpot" reward ... and multiplying it by 3 is a mistake?

or are we supposed to find 9 items in a single chest ?

this week - 2 dozen members of our coalition have received 3 legendary tier 4 generals gear coffers with keys .... times 3 (9 tier-4 generals gear) from single legendary or basic coalition chests (the reward for purchasing drachma packs that every member of our coalition gets)

one member has found this package 3 times (27 tier-4 generals gear) in one day

(some like me only found 9x tier3 uncommon items)

when these chests mostly seem to offer things like 5 drachma, a single upgrade sketch, 1000 of a resource, a single scout, other very small rewards that are not worth the time to open the chest .... it seems like 9 legendary top tier generals gear is not in sinc with the normal rewards

is this a bug?  is this supposed to be happening?