Well for what it is worth: my scouts are all t1s with their valkerie knowledge increased to 15.5% and my favorite shaman is Inga and gives no benefit to scouts (my Wendla is still lv 1 and  gives scouts only an extra 0.5% defence).

So I will stick with 0, ie 0%

the defence for the attack was 113%

however the  INCREASE was 188% 

the total INCREASE before any penalty's is 188%

the defense % at the time of the attack was 113%

pipkin said:

at least we know it is not 650% ... we have already been told by the administrator on page 26 and again page 27 that it is not 650%

Looks like no one cares 🤣🤣🤣

It is a rather interesting spectacle from a sociological point of view lol