All Categories

Mech arena would be a better game if

Search
Comments
Nov 6, 2026, 11:0811/06/26
03/24/26
1
Dragonator

Just because you can pay and still lose doesn't mean it's not pay to win. You think it's gotta have a button you can pay to press that instantly makes you win the match for it to be pay to win? And tell me what skill is there involved in pressing a button to make your weapons fire and then pressing another button to turn yourself invulnerable while they fire so you can shoot at your enemies while they can't shoot back? What skill?

And devs don't need "new and novel ideas" to replace the gambling mechanics. What value are they adding to the game?  I know some people see an opportunity to get a cheap mech, but I just see a fomo mechanic.

I am under 18, and dont earn much money and I know I dont have to spend money but it makes it insanely hard to not be a p2w.

My mum didnt let me spend any money on any game no matter what and i was ok with that, then she let me spend a little and now in like 6 months ive spent about 200 to 250 AUD, and saved about 40 AUD. It sucks.

Now no matter how much you spend on the game, even if you are on the highest level or inventory power or hangar/squad power, the game will give you people with a similar hangar/squad power, so you think you will be better than everybody, but in reality they will be on the same level as you.

Nov 16, 2026, 20:37Yesterday
09/17/21
448
Dragonator

Why did I bring up the other game? Because it's relevant to the conversation. And you know how people say that war robots is worse to excuse mech arena. Here I'm comparing it to a game that's in my in my opinion much better. I have played clash of clans. I know what it's like. You may have heard it's pay to win and sure there's an argument to be made it is. But to give some perspective, clash of clans doesn't have $100 new troops every month. You can absolutely spend a lot of money in it. And hell you probably will be if you want to ever reach max without no-lifing it. But you don't get ridiculous mismatches. And the no lifing for max applies to mech arena too.

BTW what is your current SP? Because I imagine it's not 4k if you're beating people with 8k higher hangar power than you. Let's talk percentages here. Are you going against people who have 3 times your strength? Guess what? Regardless clash of clans does not have that kind of variation in the matchmaking. They obviously have a vastly superior matchmaking system.

And you don't gotta tell me SP isn't everything. I've been saying that metric is near meaningless for actual weapon strength. But many items in the same energy category have similar SP ratings. And most things within the same energy category can be perfectly competitive weapons against each other. Except for in edge cases like sub-legendary grade or like you said, carbines. But nobody in their right mind is going to be using carbines as well most won't use the vast majority of sub-legendary mechs after a certain point. Nor are people frequently using lower than the highest grade mechs they have access to. So SP is still a pretty strong visual indicator in the gap in performance you can expect from different players' hangars.

Also "If the devs make the matchmaking 'farier', people end up abusing it more (see the influx of tankers that happened after many MM fairness changes)." Which matchmaking fairness changes? When? XP to SP sure but over time it felt like plarium had mitigated the extreme mismatches. Now we're back to people having them? And what so we say "okay this sucks but don't ask plarium to make it fairer because that makes it more 'exploitable'"? How about that fact that a more exploitable matchmaking system than the current one is inherently less fair?

And when have people not been happy about faster changes? When have they ever made drastic changes to the matchmaking besides when the it went from XP to SP based matchmaking, after gear hub came to mech arena, and the new tournaments? And I mean the actual matchmaking. XP to SP was celebrated. Gear hub is looked down upon because they updated the stats of everything without updating power ratings which made them even less meaningful than they were before, and then complicated everything with grade influenced matchmaking, which didn't work because people do not play all the same grade mechs and weapons all in the same hangar all the time. Tournament matchmaking I don't think has ever really gotten more "fair" instead it became based on tournament division, which is neutral. And it's been debated but I think it just needed a few kinks worked out. That's the only times matchmaking has really drastically changed as far as I can remember. Matchmaking for regular gamemodes still have plenty of kinks to work out. But plarium seemingly doesn't want to work on any of them. And here it's almost sounding like you're saying they shouldn't.

It's a difficult balance I'm sure that's what plarium would love us to believe it's a good excuse to not try as hard as they could be or not try at all. People don't necessarily have to lose if matchmaking functions correctly. Draws exist in the game for a reason. But how often do you draw your matches? Not often I imagine. They virtually always have a winner and a loser. Almost as if that's by design. That's not a sign of a properly working matchmaking system if you ask me. And haven't you ever wondered what such "incremental improvements" they've made? Have you ever asked what they're actually doing to improve the matchmaking? What any of these so called "incremental changes" are? Spoiler alert: THEY DON'T ANSWER!

You wrote all of that without realising my point: if SP is so inaccurate, how can you tell someone is 3 times your strength?

And strength isn't the only thing to consider - skill plays a role. Often I find the MM gives me a rather strong opponent, and I only realise when checking their hangar after I've won.

Hell, I'd argue a 12K to 20K is a much worse gap than 3K to 7K or something, even if the latter is technically a larger percentage difference.



And if you've not been living under a rock, I shouldn't have to go point out all the changes they've made to make the normal matchmaking better, and ended up also making it easier to abuse - it's happened quite a few times, which is one of the reasons they are recently more subtle with their tweaks.

If you look back when they first started doing large MM experiments with tournament, sooo many people spoke out and complained, because they did a larger test, it didn't entirely go as planned and people got mad about it.


Gear hub being "looked down upon" is your opinion. The gear hub was 100% an improvement. I wouldn't have 75% of the items I do if it wasn't for it.

Maybe you're referring to the grade update, which was good and bad. It put an end to oppression by artillery, which I sure as hell don't miss - and it made the game more intuitive. A rare and uncommon item shouldn't be top meta when legendary items are a thing. Yeah there are some things that I'd like to still want be strong, like Tengu (#BUFFTENGU, or well a legendary version (pls Plarium I need it)) - and I would've preferred if the gap had been a bit smaller - but some of those things for many players have had a legendary version release - like lacewing for lancer, nomad for killshot and such.

And you could also argue that many of the 'legendary' items should be either be buffed or reduced in grade (without touching the stats I mean), like scorpius, for this intuitiveness to really be carried all the way through - and I'd agree.


In my experience, the main issue the matchmaking has atm is a tourney one to do with large teams versus collections of randoms - both at higher and lower SP I've played a lot and the matchmaking seems generally fine.



I'm also not saying Plarium shouldn't make it fairer because it makes it more exploitable - again you've missed my point - the point was that it isn't SIMPLE. As a game I know this, matchmaking is HARD. Harder than you probably think. I mean, to maximise satisfaction, how do you make a system were everybody ends up winning >50% of the time?

I never said Plarium shouldn't work on the MM - you've entirely misunderstood what I'm saying - it's not perfect and never will be, certainly as the game continues to evolve. I'm just saying that maybe you should cut them some slack instead of deciding that it's actually as easy as clicking your fingers.

While draws exist, drawing a match is incredibly unsatisfying. You got so close to winning.. except it slightly wasn't enough.

People would rather win some and lose some instead of draw all the time.

Also, like, you are really making an argument about draws when CPC is the main gamemode most people at least prefer to play - and influence is stored as a Float, remember?


Also also, have you considered that they don't like telling how the matchmaking works for number 1 because that's basically giving away stuff that costs them money to figure out for free, and number 2 because if people know how the MM works, it makes it a lot easier to exploit.

Nov 16, 2026, 22:01Yesterday
09/08/26
93

They do tell us how the matchmaking works (supposedly) they just don't tell us how they're changing it. I'm not asking for the exact algorithm. I'm just wondering what could possibly be doing make the matchmaking smoother when it's clearly not getting smoother.

And I don't think you get what I'm saying about SP. It is inaccurate, yes. But it's more likely to be that the gap between your SP and another players represents a LARGER gap than it would first appear, rather than smaller. And I explained to you how SP though somewhat meaningless can still reliably determine the gap between your strength and another player's given you've got weapons that are all the same grade. You can assume it's larger if one of you has lower grade weapons.

BTW yes I was talking about the grade update as opposed to gear hub.

Nov 16, 2026, 22:52Yesterday
Nov 16, 2026, 23:15(edited)
09/08/26
93

What's the last time they did a major matchmaking test anyways? I know what you're talking about pogster but the last time they did one was what, 2021? When they first introduced SP based matchmaking. Yeah it was rough at first and they shifted to more minuscule changes for good reason. But AFTER they had switched to a system that was fairer to begin with. And they got to something that was manageable.

Then they added the grade update, killed a lot kf the usefulness SP ratings had for matchmaking before, and gave us a stupidly complicated system in its place. Have been making "incremental changes" ever since to no avail. And there hasn't been another matchmaking test to make the matchmaking "fairer" since. Unless you want to count tournaments which made them decidedly less fair which for tournaments if you ask me is a good thing.

But for general matchmaking there's been no tests that we're supposed to make it "fairer" since the ones in 2021. In 2025 you had the tests that attempted to resolve SP cheating. That's not to make it fairer if you ask me though it's to mitigate the exploits that come from a system that was apparently supposed to keep things fair after the grade update mucked everything up. And those apparently didn't do anything so plarium just gave up. So now like before the switch to SP based matchmaking in 2021 we're working with a fundamentally broken system. And yeah a lot of people are going to have it rough and complain if they make drastic changes now. Not like that isn't already the case or anything.

Edit: Forgot the tournament changes from 2024 which accomplished the opposite of what they said they were doing.

Nov 16, 2026, 23:21Yesterday
09/08/26
93

I'll put it this way. SP cheating was just a way to self sabotage against a skilled player before the grade update. Now it creates insurmountable gaps thanks to things like all weapons of the same energy and level having similar sp even if it's a common vs a legendary