This is going to be as expected, its not worth the while bothering with.

There is the requirement to do things not normally done,and without a stronghold the clans already 1 category down.

A separate category for points in defending, means you have to let someone attack you, which means either on tiles or leaving the town exposed. 

You mostly get attacked on tiles by much bigger players so the loss in manpower is significant, it will also mean that yielding will also be that much harder .

Of course this may be your plan.

However.

I believe its ill conceived,

Lets see how many more players quit.

Hola, me parece desorbitada la cantidad de puntos que pide para la liga que es. Deverian revisar los puntos para clanes.

Hi, I think the amount of points you ask for the league is exorbitant. They should review the points for clans.

I hope you did not get rid of the bastion town skin for reward. We love that town skin! Not everyone can achieve or like those permanent town skin with their individual bonuses and some will for sure take forever to achieve.

Bastion of the Beast was the only thing worth fighting for.  If you have taken that away then you will lose many players.   

The last point about the stronghold being completed and offering no possibilty for scoring  is exactly the same for those without one, and in some respects  no different for any of the targets set to be achieved.

Players get to the point where they cannot score in events or can score only a few levels because of constraints of the game.

As in the example of tasks refreshers, unless you have the mega amount you have you are only likely to  see three free refreshes in a day and you are talking of a maximum amount of 45 if you have reached the dizzy heights of VIP 30.

So the idea  of winning,that you can complete 10 levels, or get one of the top places is completely ridiculous.

It wouldnt surprise me to find that its better to ignore the events and just get the bank offers  to get the things needed to grow.

With out doubt one of the worst updates yet, I did not think I would see an update that actually discourages clans to fight. A clan can find great targets and out score their opponents 100 fold and still lose because it only counts for one category and in fact the attacks give the other clan defence points and let’s them heal troops. A clan that refuses to attack anything and only sends small marches will win the defence category as well. The only thing this update has done is make our life partners happy because cvc is not worth playing anymore, more time to mow the lawns everyone!

I think its a good idea to keep innovating the game and introduce new stuff. The SH defense is a good example. I like that although sometimes I get the feeling that Plarium wants to feed more on us...

But this new CvC update? Well I really hate it and lost all interest in participating like almost everyone in our clan. Maybe it works below Odin's league to give the smaller clans a chance to grow but above 5T people want to fight for their money and not farm or upgrade a SH which is already maxed..

I hope more people express themselves and it will be changed in the next update.

Bastion of the Beast was the only thing worth fighting for. We want it back!!!

Lol

Why did the other 50 reply's get archived? was is to hide the growing number of complaints?

Anyway to offer a constructive solution to the Attack/ defense points saga, why not just have points for kills defense or attack. if your good at defending you will score well. If your good at attacking you will score well. it would bring some equitable balance to this problem.

To keep to 7 task you could then split hunting invaders and ghost into separate tasks as this would help even the requirement for hero and Shaman energy. you may also like to reintroduce CvC winning Skins this too seems to be a bone of contention for all players.

Perhaps you could  consider this.

Have a good day.

xyz said:

This would be a problem  where  the clan hasn't got shaman.

I would have thought any player/Clan with 5m points to participate in CvC would have a basic shaman at least so even a small player/Clan could participate even at that small level. so it would still be fair for them as well.
Would be an incentive to get one anyway for the small guys to help them grow and participate.

Just because there is an incentive to get something doesn't mean you can get it.or have it already.  

It is possible to be in the CvC where you are small in numbers or a single player and don't have a shaman,you have to prioritise what to spent resources on, some may consider other things more important than a shaman, besides it would be a sudden change  not something like, we are going to introduce this later,so make sure you are eligible.

There is a post on here about a  clan that is in their first CvC and drawn against a clan with massive superiority over them.

They didn't mention shaman , but I would suggest  that this clan would be at a serious disadvantage against this old clan with high level of legendary  equipped hero and most likely shaman too.