A bit more info... I asked about rewards after the tournament is over. We'll be able to claim them all, as in other tournaments (so, they won't expire like with contracts/seasons), and there should be a "claim all" button where the "time remaining" timer is, so we don't die clicking.

The Bash: Was it worth it. 

1. Took a lot of time to do ll of it

2. rewards (for me) were just ok

Resource rewards were high., I don't need the res...I'm way out on builds and have a lot of back up as well.  

Don't really need idols, got many.

Bash rewards could use: more troop awards, naut charts, boosts, troop training boosts, and of course rubies. 

Winning your battle awards are very weak, weaker than many of the tournament rewards..

Takeaway: The bash was great for lower level players or lower alts, however for upper levels it was just okay.

I probably won't gt excited avout the next one iof things are the same.

Anyone on Plarium's special list (is it still active?) might want to pass on some feedback.

TheWeight said:

The Bash: Was it worth it. 

1. Took a lot of time to do ll of it

2. rewards (for me) were just ok

Resource rewards were high., I don't need the res...I'm way out on builds and have a lot of back up as well.  

Don't really need idols, got many.

Bash rewards could use: more troop awards, naut charts, boosts, troop training boosts, and of course rubies. 

Winning your battle awards are very weak, weaker than many of the tournament rewards..

Takeaway: The bash was great for lower level players or lower alts, however for upper levels it was just okay.

I probably won't gt excited avout the next one iof things are the same.

Anyone on Plarium's special list (is it still active?) might want to pass on some feedback.

Hello, Captain!

Thanks a lot for your feedback! I'm glad to hear that you think it was worth it  I hope that the future rewards won't disappoint you, too. Also, I'll make sure to forward your feedback. Cheers! 

The rewards actually seem quite nice for victorious BHs in top 10. In my BH, each of us got over 8k rubies and hundreds of units.

My BH on s1, for comparison, won, but it was a lower Tier and we didn't end up among top 10 (I think we were near #40), and we got under 1k rubies and far fewer units. Also, we're a 2 players BH that don't play much more than keeping the accounts alive.

So, not bad for literally "business as usual", as we didn't do anything specific to try to win.

I still dislike that we're encouraged to war against a randomly assigned BH, but this really didn't seem to have any impact.

Crowbar said:

I still dislike that we're encouraged to war against a randomly assigned BH, but this really didn't seem to have any impact.

I agree.  I've been parroting the leaders of our brawl opponents to ask if they wish to keep the PvP portion off the table.

IMO the PvP should be scored as general PvP not BH specific.

Prizing wins the brawls..
polish your lighthouses and get to work

Charge

oh yeah.. what's with all the little BHs anyway..
unite 50 two player BHs and rock on
you say you don't have 100  berths

have your leader buy berths 10 at a time,, it lets you acquire each ten for rum lumber & gold
each time it cost more..

you'll pay 200 or 220 K of each resource for the last 10 berths available 
at that point you have 100 berths.. 

you'll have to earn that last one to have room for 101 active players to get maximum daily BH activity rewards
now go get 'em you need to stick together to make the most of this game

So I went to bed with 4 hours left in the brawl and 15k points in the lead.  I wake up and we are 20k behind.  The brawl doesn't tell me what categories we lost in.  It doesn't tell me who contributed what points in the final hours.  I wait a couple days to see if the totals show up and the information that was there is completely gone now.

It would be appreciated if I could see the Brawl score totals accurately both DURING and AFTER the BH Brawl Event!

I would also enjoy being able to view more than the top 10 ranks.  Perhaps the top 50 or 100 BH's in our Tier.  Maybe even an option to view point totals of all individual Brawls in progress.

Crowbar said:

I still dislike that we're encouraged to war against a randomly assigned BH, but this really didn't seem to have any impact.

I agree.  I've been parroting the leaders of our brawl opponents to ask if they wish to keep the PvP portion off the table.

IMO the PvP should be scored as general PvP not BH specific.

The rewards were a heck of a lot better than a potion ye get for the challenge contest and given for tasks I already do in game.

bagnarok said:

The least you all can do is give us enough time to build our fleets after each brawl. I mean you all are not giving enough time between the brawls. It seems like you all just want us to spend more $$ and those with the deepest pockets will rule the seas. 

Hello! Thanks for sharing. This is a very popular question, to be honest. Some players think that Brotherhood Brawls should be once per week as it is now, and if someone doesn't want to participate, they can simply skip it. In the meantime, some BHs would like to see the Brawl once per month, for example.

We've discussed it with our game team before, and it was decided that as long as there are BHs ready to participate each week, we'll launch it weekly. We do hope for your understanding. Cheers! 

So I went to bed with 4 hours left in the brawl and 15k points in the lead.  I wake up and we are 20k behind.  The brawl doesn't tell me what categories we lost in.  It doesn't tell me who contributed what points in the final hours.  I wait a couple days to see if the totals show up and the information that was there is completely gone now.

It would be appreciated if I could see the Brawl score totals accurately both DURING and AFTER the BH Brawl Event!

I would also enjoy being able to view more than the top 10 ranks.  Perhaps the top 50 or 100 BH's in our Tier.  Maybe even an option to view point totals of all individual Brawls in progress.

Also, I don't get why a scout is worth so much more than a Juggernaut.  To me that point system on troop gains should be re-evaluated.  IMO it should be based off of default production times.  Winning a bunch of marines or dragon troops on a low level mission pays out more than winning juggs on a mid level mission.  Pirates also breed a lot quicker in the ques than armada.  But hey that is the devs area I'm just a player wondering why it seems so imbalanced.

Keel D. Haul said:

So I went to bed with 4 hours left in the brawl and 15k points in the lead.  I wake up and we are 20k behind.  The brawl doesn't tell me what categories we lost in.  It doesn't tell me who contributed what points in the final hours.  I wait a couple days to see if the totals show up and the information that was there is completely gone now.

It would be appreciated if I could see the Brawl score totals accurately both DURING and AFTER the BH Brawl Event!

I would also enjoy being able to view more than the top 10 ranks.  Perhaps the top 50 or 100 BH's in our Tier.  Maybe even an option to view point totals of all individual Brawls in progress.

Also, I don't get why a scout is worth so much more than a Juggernaut.  To me that point system on troop gains should be re-evaluated.  IMO it should be based off of default production times.  Winning a bunch of marines or dragon troops on a low level mission pays out more than winning juggs on a mid level mission.  Pirates also breed a lot quicker in the ques than armada.  But hey that is the devs area I'm just a player wondering why it seems so imbalanced.

Hello! Thanks for sharing your concern with us. We've discussed it with the game team before. They've promised us to think how we can implement it nicely. If the logs don't overload the game too much, it's quite possible to do it. Cheers!

Alina said:

Keel D. Haul said:

So I went to bed with 4 hours left in the brawl and 15k points in the lead.  I wake up and we are 20k behind.  The brawl doesn't tell me what categories we lost in.  It doesn't tell me who contributed what points in the final hours.  I wait a couple days to see if the totals show up and the information that was there is completely gone now.

It would be appreciated if I could see the Brawl score totals accurately both DURING and AFTER the BH Brawl Event!

I would also enjoy being able to view more than the top 10 ranks.  Perhaps the top 50 or 100 BH's in our Tier.  Maybe even an option to view point totals of all individual Brawls in progress.

Also, I don't get why a scout is worth so much more than a Juggernaut.  To me that point system on troop gains should be re-evaluated.  IMO it should be based off of default production times.  Winning a bunch of marines or dragon troops on a low level mission pays out more than winning juggs on a mid level mission.  Pirates also breed a lot quicker in the ques than armada.  But hey that is the devs area I'm just a player wondering why it seems so imbalanced.

Hello! Thanks for sharing your concern with us. We've discussed it with the game team before. They've promised us to think how we can implement it nicely. If the logs don't overload the game too much, it's quite possible to do it. Cheers!

The brawl logs do show up after a couple of game refreshes but only show the points earned by members who have NOT claimed their rewards - this needs to be changed ..... and why don't we ever see our own individual scores for each task? (except gigs)