1. Effectively would do exactly the same thing as giving items directly to clan members.

    There would be no reason to  interact with chat or clans.

     How would you see the economies of all the kingdoms?

2. Sounds too complicated.

3. Maybe they dont do as much as was intended, or as much as they did, but players still mine gold.

   If the mini pop existed , why would there be more places to fight?

   They dont fight over POP now, which might  be part  of the reasons for new introductions .

   For those interested, theres already a reason to unlock the things you suggested.

   You dont need points to grow faster, you can do this already by # harvesting from tiles... too boring you say

                                                                                                        #buying packs             too expensive and boring.

No it would not  be a replacement for the gift item,  it doesnt exist now, and for good reason.

4.Relocating Stronghold to other Kingdoms.

This would, # only move the stronghold, what about the players?

If clans wanted to,it would be no problem for them to move to a different Kingdom and build a new one... it would give them something to do.

If clans are reluctantly sharing the POP , why would you follow anyone? You would just go somewhere and hope no one else comes.

If you are happy sharing the POP why would you need to move at all?

Most clans want to be near the forest, these places would not be available in other kingdoms.

Are there any weak kingdoms? If there are, I  dont beileve weak clans would  look to move to dominate them.They would not  get a chance from the strong clans, as they dont now.

 The ranking you suggest, wiil have the effect of widening the gap, as happens with sports leagues.

WDYWTNTF said:

1. Effectively would do exactly the same thing as giving items directly to clan members.

    There would be no reason to  interact with chat or clans.

     How would you see the economies of all the kingdoms?

Plarium does not want the "gift buttom". A lot of people would stop spending money, It would also be an easier way to steal items. Making the "clan market" will require resources and boosts. 

2. Sounds too complicated.

How is that complicated? just mix 4 materials and obtain 1 randomly. 

3. Maybe they dont do as much as was intended, or as much as they did, but players still mine gold.

   If the mini pop existed , why would there be more places to fight?  

   They dont fight over POP now, which might  be part  of the reasons for new introductions . 

   For those interested, theres already a reason to unlock the things you suggested.

   You dont need points to grow faster, you can do this already by # harvesting from tiles... too boring you say

                                                                                                        #buying packs             too expensive and boring.

 Some clans make points only training, And PoP has 24h shield. Not all clans attack or set up traps in cities. This places will force the fight.

No it would not  be a replacement for the gift item,  it doesnt exist now, and for good reason.

4.Relocating Stronghold to other Kingdoms.

This would, # only move the stronghold, what about the players? The cost of moving stronghold could be the cost of moving all people in the clan at that moment. 

If clans wanted to,it would be no problem for them to move to a different Kingdom and build a new one... it would give them something to do. Nope, lvl 3 stronghold costs a lot of money. Especially if you have gears unlocked.

If clans are reluctantly sharing the POP , why would you follow anyone? You would just go somewhere and hope no one else comes. Believe it or not, there are clans that "hate" another ones. Although, 1 month waiting is not really necessary. You may be right 

If you are happy sharing the POP why would you need to move at all? You move because you don't want to share pop or you can´t get it. If you are happy sharing pop, don't move... 

Most clans want to be near the forest, these places would not be available in other kingdoms. You may be right on this. But I don't think inactive SH will stay there forever. 

Are there any weak kingdoms? If there are, I  dont beileve weak clans would  look to move to dominate them. They would not  get a chance from the strong clans, as they dont now. Of course there are weak kingdoms. Just look at kvk scores.  People who spends a lot play in the bigger clans. There are dead kingdoms with only one active clan, there are kingdoms that lose every competition and people leave. 

 The ranking you suggest, wiil have the effect of widening the gap, as happens with sports leagues.

You're wrong here, it's going to be totally the opposite. The ranking will allow "strong" clans not to go to weak kingdoms. For example: If my clan has 500b influence and the dominant clan has 1000b influence, we would like to move because we lose the pop. But we won't be allowed to move to a weaker kingdom which dominant clan has 100b influence. That would be unfair. Another solution to this, is that You won´t be able to relocate your SH if your clan's influence is higher than the top clan of the kingdom you want to go.