Your Data is flawed firstly nowhere does it say Stoneheart units are a shield or Buff for your Regular units. You can't really expect a single infantry Stone heart unit to have any significance Against a Stoneheart beast attack of that size.

If you want to test this you must attack the same number Of Occult Stoneheart units as you did the Regular Occult units With the same amount Of Stoneheart Beast Units . 

It's an expensive test  but it would most likely show a big difference

This is not a bug so i will move this to the Game discussion  area. 

wesley already explained it perfectly ,units type matter.not only that,each unit's statistic against every single unit type differ too

thats a purgator's defense stat against a gargoyle.but if u see the totals while sending it will show a diferent number.

also in pvp ,the numbers it shows are directly dependant on power point of each unit,u vant just judge by numbers,diferent units got diferent power points in defense and also in ofensive actions

u would also like to visit this page on the outcome of a battle here.

many things can and will affect the procedure u just showed

even though its not a bug,a very nice experiment ,enjoyed reading this post

Wesley Pringle said:

Your Data is flawed firstly nowhere does it say Stoneheart units are a shield or Buff for your Regular units. You can't really expect a single infantry Stone heart unit to have any significance Against a Stoneheart beast attack of that size.

If you want to test this you must attack the same number Of Occult Stoneheart units as you did the Regular Occult units With the same amount Of Stoneheart Beast Units . 

It's an expensive test  but it would most likely show a big difference

This is not a bug so i will move this to the Game discussion  area. 

1. the data isn't flawed first of all what i ask not the debuff from the lost art(stoneheart ability) but the debuff from the stoneheart that hitting non stoneheart please see the combat ability 
2. his 200 demon the defense value was the same as = with 251 purgatorydefense value when defending the beast type
3. this test was do on the non waller and the attacker and the defender was the same person
4.As you could see the one attacking was gargoyle ("beastiary type") so the demon and purgatory will defend value base on the Beast type
5. if the 200 demon status equall with 251 purgatory status in the defense beast why the result of the battle was the same where the defender lost 90% and the offense was lost on 10%? 
  

Reid Farenheid said:

as you could see that the result of the battle was the same please repair this one

what i can clearly see is that the results of the battles are different. demons lost 93,5% to 8% gargs lost and purgs lost 92% to 9% gargs lost. thats not the same.

assuming the test was done in a castle without a single wall piece and beast def value of demons and purgs used was the same your test actually proved that gargs get the bonus while fighting non-stoneheart units

Reid Farenheid said:

Wesley Pringle said:

Your Data is flawed firstly nowhere does it say Stoneheart units are a shield or Buff for your Regular units. You can't really expect a single infantry Stone heart unit to have any significance Against a Stoneheart beast attack of that size.

If you want to test this you must attack the same number Of Occult Stoneheart units as you did the Regular Occult units With the same amount Of Stoneheart Beast Units . 

It's an expensive test  but it would most likely show a big difference

This is not a bug so i will move this to the Game discussion  area. 

1. the data isn't flawed first of all what i ask not the debuff from the lost art(stoneheart ability) but the debuff from the stoneheart that hitting non stoneheart please see the combat ability 
2. his 200 demon the defense value was the same as = with 251 purgatorydefense value when defending the beast type
3. this test was do on the non waller and the attacker and the defender was the same person
4.As you could see the one attacking was gargoyle ("beastiary type") so the demon and purgatory will defend value base on the Beast type
5. if the 200 demon status equall with 251 purgatory status in the defense beast why the result of the battle was the same where the defender lost 90% and the offense was lost on 10%? 
  

I think you are  jousting against windmills If your going to make comparisons At least make them with Comparable Units  Not with units that are different Compare Occults with Occults and Infantry against Infantry That is where your Data is flawed  

Reid Farenheid said:

as you could see that the result of the battle was the same please repair this one

what i can clearly see is that the results of the battles are different. demons lost 93,5% to 8% gargs lost and purgs lost 92% to 9% gargs lost. thats not the same.

assuming the test was done in a castle without a single wall piece and beast def value of demons and purgs used was the same your test actually proved that gargs get the bonus while fighting non-stoneheart units