Hello, Lords!
This situation is not a bug. Liberation of a Castle is a defensive type of action. This is why the defensive type Champion is being selected.Agent Pavel said:
Hello, Lords!
This situation is not a bug. Liberation of a Castle is a defensive type of action. This is why the defensive type Champion is being selected.
Liberation has always been an offensive action throughout the recorded history of mankind.
Liberation has always been an offensive action throughout the recorded history of Stormfall.
To liberate is 'to free'.
Freedom has never been obtained without force. Force is an offensive action.
Fundamentally, to liberate is to free, which requires an offensive action to perform.Limad said:
Nobody libs def with def. You don't play the game, Pavel.Fundamentally Pavel would be correct, but this STORMFALL.
Not all works like it should.
And that only applies if someone were to leave offense on the siege, most know better... So offense is the key,,, defense has been made rediculous here.
When you try to liberate a Castle, you receive the Reinforcements window. After the Liberation, your troops do not return to your Castle and remain at the Castle as reinforcements.
I understand that you use offensive troops to Liberate the Castle and then recall them. However, the game feature works as intended.
The reported case cannot be classified as a bug since this is a part of the regular gameplay. I have moved your topic to Game Discussion thread.
dear lords
i think you have to send the offensive troops to the siege as reinforcements to liberta so the champion should be offensive.
also if you want to send offensive to an allie to do the league attack you should be able to choose the ofensive champion
hope the devs take note and give the option depending if you send offensive or defensive reinforcements
RegardsI wont start new topic, because matter is similar to that old one. I have question to make sure if thing which I search dont exist, not that I cant find it.... When I send defensive champion to someone castle as reinforcement, there is no option to activate it. And when castle got hit, I saw on my message that "no element was selected" so I instantly lost against enemy champion. If there is option to select it pls point me it, if not- it is game mistake which I want report, since it should automaticly choose element with most champions in army according to champions note.
Mixtyson said:
I wont start new topic, because matter is similar to that old one. I have question to make sure if thing which I search dont exist, not that I cant find it.... When I send defensive champion to someone castle as reinforcement, there is no option to activate it. And when castle got hit, I saw on my message that "no element was selected" so I instantly lost against enemy champion. If there is option to select it pls point me it, if not- it is game mistake which I want report, since it should automaticly choose element with most champions in army according to champions note.
Hello!
When you send a Champion as Reinforcement, he gives Bonuses only to your Units.
Player to whom you send this Reinforcement, can't activate your Champion. He can do it only with his own Champions.
You received "no element was selected" as he doesn't have any active Champion in the Castle.
It's not a bug. It's how the feature is meant to work.
Dear Lords
what i can see is that the castle defense champion is only for ur castle and that is why you cant send them to reinforce another lord castle
is the same as champions for beacons defense cant be sent to fortress defense
at least is that way as i understand the champion castle defense and that is why its not consider a bug
the same way you cant send your spy champion to spy another castle with your spies.
let me know if im wrong
RegardsLord Sir Dan
again, offensive champions can be used in all attacks actions cause that is their role...to raid and to siege
defensive champions its only for your castle as resources champions and spy champions. the defensive champion has its own slot to be estacioned on your castle not on everyones castle. It does not work for allies castles or other defending action if not only for ur castle
you cant send it in any defensive action cause it is not its role only giving you and extra when ur castle is attacking
again. its not a bug. its how the defensive champion works....only for your castle...if you want a defensive champion for reinforcements devs will have to launch a champion what can do that.
:)
peace and GG
Juglar del Viento said:
Dear Lords
what i can see is that the castle defense champion is only for ur castle and that is why you cant send them to reinforce another lord castle
is the same as champions for beacons defense cant be sent to fortress defense
at least is that way as i understand the champion castle defense and that is why its not consider a bug
the same way you cant send your spy champion to spy another castle with your spies.
let me know if im wrong
Regards
You are not right. It is possible to send them (to make thing more funny you can not only send your spy champion with spying attempt, you can also send him with your spies as reinforcement), but they just DONT work. I found it as VERY BAD solved. People send champions, keep in different castle, and there is no information that champions "can be use only in your castle". So it is a bug, or intentionally misleading
Not true. Offensive champions can not be sent in offensive liberation attacks.
again, offensive champions can be used in all attacks actions cause that is their role...to raid and to siege
Aegon Targaryen said:
Juglar del Viento said:
Not true. Offensive champions can not be sent in offensive liberation attacks.again, offensive champions can be used in all attacks actions cause that is their role...to raid and to siege
Dear Lord
i think i said nothing about liberation....
Regardsyou said all attack actions. Liberation is an attack action.Aegon Targaryen said:
Juglar del Viento said:
Not true. Offensive champions can not be sent in offensive liberation attacks.again, offensive champions can be used in all attacks actions cause that is their role...to raid and to siege
Dear Lord
i think i said nothing about liberation....
Regards
Juglar del Viento said:
again, offensive champions can be used in all attacks actions cause that is their role...to raid and to siege
Actually you are wrong,or i misunderstand you. You can use your deffensive champ in other castles, but will give bonuses only to your troops. And i mean other castles, as reinfrcement or as sieges. Your troops used in those actions will get the champ bonuses. The only thing that dosent work, is to choose your elemen. But that also work as in your castle when you didnt choose an element. If your champ have a stronger element than the oponent, your champ will get the 25% bonus in other castles also, with the single condition that the castle owner to not have a champ active in his castle. In that situation, his champ element will set the rules in fight.Lord Sir Dan
again, offensive champions can be used in all attacks actions cause that is their role...to raid and to siege
defensive champions its only for your castle as resources champions and spy champions. the defensive champion has its own slot to be estacioned on your castle not on everyones castle. It does not work for allies castles or other defending action if not only for ur castle
you cant send it in any defensive action cause it is not its role only giving you and extra when ur castle is attacking
again. its not a bug. its how the defensive champion works....only for your castle...if you want a defensive champion for reinforcements devs will have to launch a champion what can do that.
:)
peace and GG
When capturing any Hamlet I get to CHOOSE which Champion to send - http://prntscr.com/lhcewt
I can send offense OR defense
It should be exactly the same for ALL reinforce attempts ... makes no difference whether I intend to reinforce or liberate, or just send offense to a league member for a League Attack
Just give us a choice and the problem is solved
Snowgoon said:
When capturing any Hamlet I get to CHOOSE which Champion to send - http://prntscr.com/lhcewt
I can send offense OR defense
It should be exactly the same for ALL reinforce attempts ... makes no difference whether I intend to reinforce or liberate, or just send offense to a league member for a League Attack
Just give us a choice and the problem is solved
yep i agree with you and that is what i said to them since the first moment .... to allow send the champions for league attacks for beacons
in some way is a nosense having a great beacon champion and cant use it cause you cant send it for a league attack
i think the devs are aware of this and thinking to change and hope they can change it soon
RegardsJust don't hold your breath - it could take them 3 years to decideSnowgoon said:
When capturing any Hamlet I get to CHOOSE which Champion to send - http://prntscr.com/lhcewt
I can send offense OR defense
It should be exactly the same for ALL reinforce attempts ... makes no difference whether I intend to reinforce or liberate, or just send offense to a league member for a League Attack
Just give us a choice and the problem is solved
yep i agree with you and that is what i said to them since the first moment .... to allow send the champions for league attacks for beacons
in some way is a nosense having a great beacon champion and cant use it cause you cant send it for a league attack
i think the devs are aware of this and thinking to change and hope they can change it soon
Regards
