Definitely not Warmaster if your intention is using him in arena. WM is great for dungeon bosses and CB, but it's almost completely uesless in arena.
Whether you get Helmsmasher is entirely dependent on whether your team is running a reliable DEF down comp. If you can consistently get DEF down on your target before MK attacks, then you don't need Helmsmasher, because their DEF will already be crippled, and his A2 already ignores 50% DEF.
But most teams running MK are not expected to have him be acting before the enemy, which means you usually can't rely on them having reduced armor. I think there's certainly an argument to be made for running Flawless Execution, but my guess is that Helmsmasher will be more useful overall.
HelmSmasher, Unshakable, or Elixir of Life are the only 3 Tier 6 Masteries I have seen people use on a PVP M.K
- HelmSmasher is used for more general damage because it gives extra 25% ignore defense when it procs.
- Unshakable is used for High Resistance Set Up's.
- Elixir of Life can be used for Shield Set Wearing M.K's.
M.King has the highest Health in the game so sometimes people put him in a shield set & try to stack up crazy high amounts of Health on him.