CB drop rates are not determind by someone doing more damage than others. It's simply doing enough damage to reach that chest bracket.
For example, the Ultimate chest on NM needs 39166k damage, which is about 39 million. Once you get over 39 million damage then you are eligable for that chest, with the percentage drop rates that it comes with. Getting 100 million at that point doesn't give you any better odds of getting good gear from the chest. 100 million and 40 million both result in the same chest with the same drop chances.
In other words, don't aim to be the highest damage dealer in the clan. If you can comfortablly get 40 million on NM with 1 or 2 keys, then you are better off using your other keys to hit Brutal, and then Hard, to get more chests.